Home » popular » Farm water system ‘madness’

Farm water system ‘madness’

THE current water allocation system confronting struggling farmers has been described as “extortion”.

Citing a Kerang district farmer’s financial plight, Independent Senator for Victoria, John Madigan has told Parliament that real people are facing immeasurable hardship because of the current structure of the water market. Senator Madigan compared the $13 billion budget of the Murray Darling Basin Plan with a struggling farming family pushed to the brink to pay their bills. 

In an impassioned speech in the Senate, he spoke of “real people facing immeasurable hardship, real people facing loss, real people getting out of bed every day and facing the increasing challenge of survival”.

Senator Madigan quoted extensively from a letter received from a constituent, the wife of a farmer in the Shire of Gannawarra.

Senator Madigan outlined the family-of-four’s budget after costs, which left them with $1527 a month for food, clothes, school fees, household accounts as well as repairs and maintenance to their home.

Quoting from the letter, Senator Madigan said: “In the country’s wisdom, water has been sold away from the land holders. Now it becomes a game for the investors who wait until farmers are desperate. They wait until it’s so dry that farmers have to buy water to keep their animals alive. Speculators wait until then because that is when they will make the biggest profit.”

In the letter, June [not her real name] explained her farm was entitled to usage of 385 megalitres of water on the current market. The cost for one season would be $103,950. If the family attempted to buy the right permanently, it would cost $847,000.

“This is madness,” Senator Madigan said.

“This is extortion.”

And quoting again from the letter: “Surely by now you can see how this system cannot possibly work. Farmers are being stripped bare, paying premium prices, selling at ridiculously low prices and being charged for the freight. Meanwhile forests are burning down because they are not grazed and there is too much fuel on the ground. Rivers are going stagnant and growing algae because of the lack of flow.

“Good healthy Australian produce is being decimated and replaced on the supermarket shelves with imported products not grown to our exacting standards, imported products full of chemicals and enhancers that are being fed to an ever-increasing society with major health issues. What happened to common sense?”

Senator Madigan told the Senate he would support amendments to the Water Act.

“I do not support the Plan, but I will vote in support of these amendments,” Senator Madigan said. 

“If they bring only a pinch of improvement and relief for our farmers and our irrigators, they deserve to be passed. But may this be only the start of the return of common-sense to our agricultural and water policy in this country.” 

• A full transcript of the speech can be find at: http://www.johnmadigan.com.au/speeches/realcostofwater

Digital Editions


More News

  • What made news across Gannawarra in April 2025

    What made news across Gannawarra in April 2025

    Tuesday, 1 April • Challengers to the Coalition-held seats of Mallee and Farrer faced one of the toughest tasks in federal politics ahead of the 3 May election. Prime Minister…

  • Total fire ban extended statewide for Sunday

    Total fire ban extended statewide for Sunday

    AS fires continue to rage across central and north-east Victoria, a total fire ban has been declared for Victoria today, Sunday, 11 January. A statewide TFB has been in place…

  • Prepare growers for participation

    Prepare growers for participation

    GRAIN growers seeking to build leadership skills and play a greater role in industry decision making are being encouraged to apply for GrainGrowers’ OnBoard program, a professional development initiative that…

  • Total fire ban declared for Saturday

    Total fire ban declared for Saturday

    A TOTAL fire ban has been declared for whole state of Victoria tomorrow. Tomorrow’s conditions will be cooler than today, but still warm with strong winds across the state particularly…

  • Council adopts policy on how it engages

    Council adopts policy on how it engages

    GANNAWARRA Shire Council has adopted a new strategy to guide how it engages with the community over the next four years. The council endorsed its 2026–2030 Community Engagement Strategy last…

  • People urged to get breast screening

    People urged to get breast screening

    BreastScreen Victoria’s pink mobile screening van is visiting Kerang this month. Women and trans and gender-diverse people aged 50 to 74, without breast symptoms, are encouraged to book a free,…

  • Woorinen out for revenge

    Woorinen out for revenge

    Woorinen v Wandella WOORINEN will be out for revenge this weekend when they host Wandella at Woorinen Recreation Reserve, with plenty on the line for both sides. The Tigers are…

  • Crucial clash for finals

    Crucial clash for finals

    CRICKET returns tomorrow as St Mary’s Tyntynder and Ultima Tuf meet in a crucial clash with finals implications. The two sides sit third and fourth on the ladder, level on…

  • Danger day as fires erupt

    Danger day as fires erupt

    THE tinderbox Mallee district has been spared serious fires this week, but locals are urged to be ready today, with weather conditions deteriorating and the looming real threat of fires.…

  • Prepare to act

    Prepare to act

    WITH tomorrow’s fire danger forecast to be the worst across Victoria since Black Summer in 2019-20, the State Control Centre has issued statewide Prepare Now advice, with early action recommended.…