Home » Letters to the Editor » Spurious claims on shooting

Spurious claims on shooting

THE chief executive of Field & Game Australia waxes lyrical about Australia’s “deep-seated hunting tradition” (Anger over go-ahead, Gannawarra Times, February 20).

He overlooks the deep-seated community rejection of duck shooting that led to a ban across two-thirds of our continent (NSW, Queensland and WA).

Professor Kingsford (UNSW) has surveyed waterbirds over four decades, revealing long-term decline of most hunted species. That’s awkward for shooters, so they snipe at his work.

In 2021, Kingsford finally refuted those criticisms, but the Andrews government had already promised millions of our taxes for new surveys and computer models. This is the “scientifically driven season-setting process” touted by FGA.

Last year, the Game Management Authority aimed for a reduced harvest because duck populations had not recovered despite rains. The computer model came up with a lower bag limit and the Minister even shortened GMA’s recommended season. The result? The harvest was bang-on the long-term average – no reduction at all.

Few would believe FGA’s spurious claim that “scientific research” shows the recreational shooting of Australian native ducks and quail has a “positive impact on habitat conservation and wildlife management”.

Finally, it’s a bit rich for FGA to label its opponents a “minority”. Only two in a thousand Victorians shoot ducks. And a 2019 government report disclosed that most game hunters don’t belong to any hunting club at all.

Em Wilkinson

Wattle Park, Victoria

Digital Editions


More News

  • Measles cases rise as health officials warn of vaccination gaps

    Measles cases rise as health officials warn of vaccination gaps

    HEALTH authorities are urging people to check their vaccination status as measles cases rise across Victoria. The Loddon Mallee Public Health Unit is calling on the community to ensure they…

  • Firewood collection areas now open

    Firewood collection areas now open

    VICTORIANS can now collect free firewood for personal use from designated state forest firewood collection areas. Due to ongoing elevated fire risk, the season will start on 1 April in…

  • Why strategic planning is essential for growing regional businesses

    Regional businesses play a vital role in supporting local communities across Australia. From agriculture and retail to services and manufacturing, these businesses contribute significantly to employment and economic growth in…

  • Expanding care at chemists

    Expanding care at chemists

    THE oral contraceptive pill will be available to women over 18 without a script at participating pharmacies from July, as the State Government expands the Chemist Care Now initiative. Participating…

  • Year in review December

    Year in review December

    Tuesday, 2 December THE Victorian Government approved a key work plan for VHM Limited’s Goschen Rare Earths and Mineral Sands Project in the Mallee. The project was said to increase…

  • Rams make history

    Rams make history

    MURRAY Downs have claimed victory their very first Northern Valley premiership with a nail-biting finish that went down to the very last end. The final score was 52 shots to…

  • One win from glory

    One win from glory

    2025-26 SWAN HILL & DISTRICT CRICKET ASSOCIATION A GRADE GRAND FINAL RSL v BARHAM-KOONDROOK SATURDAY, MARCH 7 SWAN HILL RECREATION RESERVE, 12.30pm Both Barham-Koondrook and RSL will be chasing grand…

  • Tourist in your own backyard

    Tourist in your own backyard

    Discover the beautiful New South Wales riverside town of Barham in The Murray River Region. A popular holiday destination, visitors to Barham can also enjoy bushwalking, swimming, canoeing and fishing…

  • Date declared for Farrer by-election

    Date declared for Farrer by-election

    THE by-election for Farrer will be held on Saturday 9 May, following the recent resignation of Sussan Ley who had held the seat since 2001. Nominations will close 13 April…

  • VEC proposes new accessibility measures

    VEC proposes new accessibility measures

    THE Victorian Electoral Commission has proposed a range of reforms aimed at making voting more accessible, as part of its submission to the Victorian Parliament’s Electoral Matters Committee inquiry into…