Home » Letters to the Editor » Where are the birds?

Where are the birds?

IN the Gannawarra Times (April 26, 2023) North Central Catchment Management Authority (NCCMA) announced that they have planned an “environmental flow in Gunbower Forest in winter and spring”.

Thus the forest will be receiving its third environmental flow since April 2021 in addition to the recent large natural flood.

The reason given is based on bird breeding as “waterbird surveys over spring and summer conservatively recorded more than 1000 juvenile waterbirds in Gunbower Forest, most of which hatched within the forest”.

NCCMA chief executive Brad Drust then goes on to add, “We have an opportunity for the first time on the floodplain to build on a significant waterbird breeding event with a follow-up flow from our Hipwell Road channel, help these young birds survive to adulthood, and help their parents rebuild condition after raising their chicks”.

The only problem being there is not 1500 (juveniles plus adults) in the forest and an inspection of the lagoons and swamps in the forest reveals no sign(s) of the 250+ nests that would be required.

In the 10 years since environmental watering began, the most nests that has ever been recorded in the forest was 48 by Birdlife Australia in 2018, hence several questions need to be answered:

A. What is going to attract these birds to the forest considering all that is going to occur is “just add water”?

B. Where are these birds going to come from?

C. At a recent meeting, NCCMA were not able to produce a “carp management strategy”, nor provide any actions that had been taken before the last flood, so are we in for a repeat of the carp fiasco?

In the media release, it mentions a list of possible reasons, given by the CSIRO, as to why there might be a high mortality rate. There is no mention of a shortage of water.

Community consultation consisted of our representative being told that the watering was going to occur.

Geoff Wakeman

Environmental committee

Central Murray Environmental Floodplain Group Chair

Digital Editions


  • Simply the best

    Simply the best

    AUDIENCES are preparing to be transported back in time as the critically acclaimed drag tribute show A Night with Tina arrives in Swan Hill next…

More News

  • Motown magic hits as Big Chill comes alive

    Motown magic hits as Big Chill comes alive

    A HIT film that helped revive a music empire is roaring back to life, with powerhouse voices and a live band bringing the soul of a generation to Australian stages.…

  • Cross-border crime crackdown

    Cross-border crime crackdown

    A MAN has been hit with 26 charges after police uncovered a stash of allegedly stolen vehicles, machinery, weapons and drugs during a cross-border crime crackdown at a Murray Downs…

  • Three-way Nationals race looms

    Three-way Nationals race looms

    A THREE-way contest is set to decide the next Nationals candidate for one of northern Victoria’s safest seats, with party members to choose a successor to retiring heavyweight Peter Walsh…

  • Walk in the park for Parkinson’s

    Walk in the park for Parkinson’s

    A REGIONAL Parkinson’s walk is set to bring communities together this weekend, with organisers urging locals to step out, connect and support those living with the condition. Swan Hill Parkinson’s…

  • Central Murray Football Round 2 Previews

    Central Murray Football Round 2 Previews

    Hay v Moulamein BOTH Hay and Moulamein will go into tomorrow’s all-important clash without several key players, as early season injuries begin to take their toll on both clubs. The…

  • Farmers welcome ministers

    Farmers welcome ministers

    VICTORIA’S peak farming body has welcomed a fresh ministerial line-up, declaring it is ready to get straight to work in what looms as a critical year for the sector. The…

  • Reporting issues after hours

    Reporting issues after hours

    RESIDENTS and visitors needing to report issues relating to animal-related matters or road and building concerns within the Gannawarra Shire Council can now do so via a new after-hours phone…

  • Magpies hold on to win thriller

    Magpies hold on to win thriller

    LAKE Boga has edged out Cohuna in a thrilling one-goal victory to begin their 2026 campaign in style, with the contest going down to the wire after an intensely fought…

  • Magpies win thriller

    Magpies win thriller

    A DETERMINED Lake Boga withstood a desperate Cohuna Kangas outfit in nail-biting finish, with the Magpies claiming a two-point victory in windy conditions. After a seesawing first round battle, it…

  • Low-sensory centres for accessible voting

    Low-sensory centres for accessible voting

    VOTING at the next Victorian state election will be more accessible for people who face barriers at traditional polling places with the rollout of low-sensory mobile voting centres. Low‑sensory voting…