Home » Letters to the Editor » No doubt on buyback impact

No doubt on buyback impact

COMMENTARY continues around the Murray-Darling Basin Plan changes being proposed by Water Minister Tanya Plibersek.

What is most concerning is her own comments, which show a serious lack of understanding around the importance of water for growing food, and the impact on communities from recovering the additional 450GL.

Unfortunately, for political reasons, she shows little acknowledgement of the potential to adopt solutions that would negate the need for damaging buybacks.

It is no wonder Ms Plibersek refuses to visit the regions of northern Victoria and southern NSW that will be impacted by her penchant to prioritise environmental and South Australian votes over what is in the best interests of our nation’s future.

If she continued with the arguments she has used thus far she would be made to look rather stupid by local people who have lived experience with water policy and management, rather than a brief introduction from conflicted bureaucrats who are generally focused on supporting a minister’s ideologies to save their jobs.

Ms Plibersek has argued the impact of recovering the additional 450GL is “overstated” as are, she says, claims around increases to the cost of food. Such comments do little other than highlight the minister’s naivety.

Quite simply, recovering the water through buybacks will lead to job losses and business closures, as has been proven beyond doubt with past buybacks.

Stuart Hipwell,

Wunghnu

Digital Editions


More News

  • Holidaymaking firefighters give a helping hand

    Holidaymaking firefighters give a helping hand

    FIREFIGHTERS who holiday near three Gannawarra Shire-based CFA brigades are being called to action, with a popular program heading to the Mallee just in time for the Easter rush. CFA’s…

  • Street program works begin

    Street program works begin

    PEDESTRIANS and motorists will soon benefit from two road safety improvement projects in Kerang. Work started last week on two projects thanks to the Victorian Government though the Safe Local…

  • Free daytime electricity

    Free daytime electricity

    GANNAWARRA residents will soon be able to tap into free daytime electricity under a major new energy plan aimed at slashing household bills. The Midday Power Saver, announced by the…

  • Murray River boom as tourists pour in and spend big

    Murray River boom as tourists pour in and spend big

    THE Murray region is riding a tourism wave, pulling in a staggering $2.52 billion from visitors in 2025 and cementing its place as one of Australia’s toughest and most appealing…

  • Straub eyes Nationals pre-selection

    Straub eyes Nationals pre-selection

    LODDON Shire Mayor Dan Straub could still throw his big hat into the ring in seeking National Party pre-selection for the Murray Plains electorate. He confirmed he was “very, very…

  • Proud moment for Prout

    Proud moment for Prout

    LEITCHVILLE-Gunbower product Logan Prout will join six-man leadership group to guide Carlton’s VFL side during the 2026 season. Prout joins Darcy Tucker, Ethan Phillips, Jack Sammartino, Will Cookson and Cooper…

  • Financial benefits of a tradie career start from day one, HIA says

    Financial benefits of a tradie career start from day one, HIA says

    ANALYSIS by the Housing Industry Association (HIA) shows that there can be immediate financial benefits for young people taking up a trade in comparison to tertiary education. HIA executive director…

  • Candidates urged to get election ready

    Candidates urged to get election ready

    REGISTERED political parties and prospective candidates for the 2026 state election are being urged to familiarise themselves with the regulatory requirements and avoid costly mistakes by registering for a series…

  • Water cheats fined

    Water cheats fined

    A CRACKDOWN on water theft in the Riverina has seen five licence holders hit with more than $77,000 in fines after allegedly taking huge volumes of groundwater they were not…

  • Hopeful faults EU trade deal

    Hopeful faults EU trade deal

    THE recent trade deal between Australia and the European Union, which aims to make it easier and cheaper for both sides to buy and sell goods and services, is going…