Home » Letters to the Editor » Leaders spread referendum fear

Leaders spread referendum fear

THE lack of political goodwill and leadership in the lead-up to and immediately after the Voice referendum was extraordinary.

We were told the cynical lie that constitutional recognition of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people through a Voice would separate Australians by race. In truth, it would have shown that we are proud of this country’s 60,000-plus years of history and that we want to grow and heal as a nation.

We were told a constitutional Voice should not come to fruition because it didn’t have 100 per cent buy in from First Australians. What a silly proposition that defies common sense and the results from individual voting booths show what we always knew to be the case. There was strong support for a Voice in First Peoples communities.

We were also told that it was Anthony Albanese’s referendum. This could not have been further from the truth. It was prime minister Malcolm Turnbull and opposition leader Bill Shorten who, in 2015, made a bipartisan decision to appoint a referendum council. The council’s job was to consult with Indigenous Australians and the broader community about how a path to constitutional recognition could be achieved.

This process culminated in an invitation from First Nations people to us, the people, asking us to walk with them. The invitation was superbly articulated in the Uluru Statement from the Heart. Last year, their request to ask the Australian people to allow an outdated Constitution to be amended finally wasn’t ignored.

With every new analysis of the referendum that appears, excuses for our failure to make sensible and much-needed change continue to roll in. It was such a small ask. Concocted arguments and a fear campaign are evidence of a superiority complex reminiscent of colonial Australia that has again played a huge role in our lack of progress on reconciliation.

While trying to come to terms with the result, I’ll continue to come back to the fact that millions of Australians wanted to walk together with our First Peoples. Millions of Australians were listening and still are.

I cannot overstate my respect and admiration for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, who have reacted to the result of the referendum with such dignity after such a challenging time.

If you haven’t read the open letter to the Prime Minister and members of the Commonwealth Parliament from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander leaders, community members and organisations who supported the “yes” case, please do. It explains what has taken place during this moment in our history better than I ever could. I guess the reason why is that it comes from the heart, just as the Uluru Statement did.

Karen Smith

Swan Hill

Digital Editions


More News

  • Golden opportunity for future

    Golden opportunity for future

    THE Victorian Farmers Federation has called on the State Government to make strategic investments in agriculture, saying smarter policy and targeted funding in seven priority areas could supercharge the industry…

  • Growers warn of fallout from visa cuts

    Growers warn of fallout from visa cuts

    UNPICKED crops, decimated rural communities and higher supermarket prices are among the consequences that could unfold if One Nation’s anti-immigration policy were to be implemented, farmers and experts have warned.…

  • Warm weather set to continue

    Warm weather set to continue

    BARLEY prices are supported as drought speculation builds, with growers holding onto grain for livestock feed. The Bureau of Meteorology January drought statement showed below-average rainfall for much of Victoria…

  • Grant strengthens cattle and red meat industry

    Grant strengthens cattle and red meat industry

    Meat and Livestock Australia (MLA) in partnership with industry peak bodies, has secured a grant from the National Foundation for Australia-China Relations to deliver a major new initiative designed to…

  • Microbiome delivering maximum results

    Microbiome delivering maximum results

    STRONG roots and fibrous stems have proven hardy resistance to excessive heat, and saved a young nursery from devastating losses. Permaculturist Russell Calder did not lose a single plant through…

  • Climate-hardy seedlings

    Climate-hardy seedlings

    DECORATIVE shrubs, trees and ground cover propagated, grafted and grown in Nyah have been designed to withstand harsh Mallee conditions. The centrepiece of the Calder Nurseries Australia collection is the…

  • Independent actionable research

    Independent actionable research

    MAKING informed winter cropping decisions – based on detailed local research – is what is driving the 2026 Irrigation Farmers Network (IFN) Winter Variety Trials Research Results Discussion Day in…

  • Cohuna Golf on track for redemption

    Cohuna Golf on track for redemption

    COHUNA Golf will march on towards their second grand final in a row, after defeating Murray Downs in comfortable fashion last Saturday. They will have a much-deserved weekend off as…

  • SHDCA Round 13 Match Reports

    SHDCA Round 13 Match Reports

    St Mary’s-Tyntynder v Wandella WANDELLA’S finals destiny remains in their own hands after defeating St Mary’s-Tyntynder by 63 runs at the Ken Harrison Reserve on Saturday. After winning the toss…

  • Bowls Notes

    Bowls Notes

    KERANG WHAT a splendid sight our club presented on Saturday as we hosted the first and second semi-finals of Saturday Pennant. Members put in a tremendous effort to ensure the…