Home » Letters to the Editor » Spurious claims on shooting

Spurious claims on shooting

THE chief executive of Field & Game Australia waxes lyrical about Australia’s “deep-seated hunting tradition” (Anger over go-ahead, Gannawarra Times, February 20).

He overlooks the deep-seated community rejection of duck shooting that led to a ban across two-thirds of our continent (NSW, Queensland and WA).

Professor Kingsford (UNSW) has surveyed waterbirds over four decades, revealing long-term decline of most hunted species. That’s awkward for shooters, so they snipe at his work.

In 2021, Kingsford finally refuted those criticisms, but the Andrews government had already promised millions of our taxes for new surveys and computer models. This is the “scientifically driven season-setting process” touted by FGA.

Last year, the Game Management Authority aimed for a reduced harvest because duck populations had not recovered despite rains. The computer model came up with a lower bag limit and the Minister even shortened GMA’s recommended season. The result? The harvest was bang-on the long-term average – no reduction at all.

Few would believe FGA’s spurious claim that “scientific research” shows the recreational shooting of Australian native ducks and quail has a “positive impact on habitat conservation and wildlife management”.

Finally, it’s a bit rich for FGA to label its opponents a “minority”. Only two in a thousand Victorians shoot ducks. And a 2019 government report disclosed that most game hunters don’t belong to any hunting club at all.

Em Wilkinson

Wattle Park, Victoria

Digital Editions


More News

  • Police appeal for dashcam footage for Barham Road crash

    Police appeal for dashcam footage for Barham Road crash

    Police are appealing for information following a serious truck and car crash near Barham on Tuesday morning. About 9.10am on February 10, emergency services were called to Barham Road, near…

  • Pool party to make a splash

    Pool party to make a splash

    HEADSPACE Swan Hill will be making a splash on Monday for their 10th birthday, celebrating 10 years of making positive waves in young people’s lives. Entry to the pool will…

  • MP welcomes bushfire probe

    MP welcomes bushfire probe

    A NORTH Victorian upper house MP has welcomed the announcement of a Parliamentary inquiry set to investigate bushfires that burned parts of the state last month. The push for the…

  • Muslims vow legal action after clash

    Muslims vow legal action after clash

    SYDNEY: A group of praying Muslim men who were ripped from their knees by police have vowed to take legal action, as an expert maintains the importance of police de-escalation.…

  • Meeting for Liberal leadership spill requested

    Meeting for Liberal leadership spill requested

    CANBERRA: Two key backers of Angus Taylor have formally requested a party room meeting, where the conservative MP will challenge Sussan Ley for the job of Opposition leader. Opposition assistant…

  • Massive Mallee drug bust

    Massive Mallee drug bust

    MILLIONS of dollars worth of cannabis plants have been seized by police just south of Kerang in what is one of the largest drug busts in the region’s history. Four…

  • Cohuna childcare: have your say

    Cohuna childcare: have your say

    CONSTRUCTION has begun at the Early Learning Centre in Cohuna, which is set to open in 2027 and eventually provide long day care, three-year-old kindergarten, and pre-prep programs for up…

  • Parkes opens author talk series

    Parkes opens author talk series

    CRIME fiction novelist and rugby writer Geoff Parkes will open the Gannawarra Library Service’s author talks 2026 program as its first featured guest. Parkes, author of When the Deep Dark…

  • Funding for young people making a difference

    Funding for young people making a difference

    The Foundation for Rural Regional Renewal and ABC Heywire are inviting local not-for-profit organisations to join forces with young changemakers and come up with ways to deal with issues concerning…

  • Firefighting competition heading to Stawell

    Firefighting competition heading to Stawell

    THE Country Fire Authority is encouraging local brigades to get a team together for this year’s state firefighter championships before registrations close this week. This year’s CFA/VFBV State Firefighter Championships…