Home » Letters to the Editor » Spurious claims on shooting

Spurious claims on shooting

THE chief executive of Field & Game Australia waxes lyrical about Australia’s “deep-seated hunting tradition” (Anger over go-ahead, Gannawarra Times, February 20).

He overlooks the deep-seated community rejection of duck shooting that led to a ban across two-thirds of our continent (NSW, Queensland and WA).

Professor Kingsford (UNSW) has surveyed waterbirds over four decades, revealing long-term decline of most hunted species. That’s awkward for shooters, so they snipe at his work.

In 2021, Kingsford finally refuted those criticisms, but the Andrews government had already promised millions of our taxes for new surveys and computer models. This is the “scientifically driven season-setting process” touted by FGA.

Last year, the Game Management Authority aimed for a reduced harvest because duck populations had not recovered despite rains. The computer model came up with a lower bag limit and the Minister even shortened GMA’s recommended season. The result? The harvest was bang-on the long-term average – no reduction at all.

Few would believe FGA’s spurious claim that “scientific research” shows the recreational shooting of Australian native ducks and quail has a “positive impact on habitat conservation and wildlife management”.

Finally, it’s a bit rich for FGA to label its opponents a “minority”. Only two in a thousand Victorians shoot ducks. And a 2019 government report disclosed that most game hunters don’t belong to any hunting club at all.

Em Wilkinson

Wattle Park, Victoria

Digital Editions


  • Early test for Blues, Swans

    Early test for Blues, Swans

    THE A grade competition will get their first big insight into the new era of the Central Murray when Murrabit hosts league heavyweights Swan Hill…

More News

  • Telemetry upgrades provide benefit

    Telemetry upgrades provide benefit

    ACCESS to water-use data has significantly improved for a number of Goulburn-Murray Water (GMW) customers thanks to a recently completed telemetry project. The GMW project has seen 82 telemeters installed…

  • Disease detection for livestock

    Disease detection for livestock

    A SENIOR veterinary officer is encouraging Victorian Farmers to monitor animals for early detection of exotic diseases. In a recent statement, Agriculture Victoria senior veterinary officer Jeff Cave highlighted the…

  • Simply the best

    Simply the best

    AUDIENCES are preparing to be transported back in time as the critically acclaimed drag tribute show A Night with Tina arrives in Swan Hill next month. The spectacular production promises…

  • Fuel crisis

    Fuel crisis

    AUSTRALIANS are still shaking their heads in dismay after expecting a statesman’s address from the Prime Minister during the fuel crisis, but instead Australians got a dubious $20 million ad…

  • First game in Central Murray league

    First game in Central Murray league

    First win in Central Murray MOULAMEIN has had their first win in the Central Murray league. This was a big day for our small club. To move into a new…

  • Council connects

    Council connects

    RESIDENTS will be able to discuss their concerns with Gannawarra Shire Council leaders thanks to a new community engagement campaign that begins later this month. The Connect With Council program…

  • Motown magic hits as Big Chill comes alive

    Motown magic hits as Big Chill comes alive

    A HIT film that helped revive a music empire is roaring back to life, with powerhouse voices and a live band bringing the soul of a generation to Australian stages.…

  • Cross-border crime crackdown

    Cross-border crime crackdown

    A MAN has been hit with 26 charges after police uncovered a stash of allegedly stolen vehicles, machinery, weapons and drugs during a cross-border crime crackdown at a Murray Downs…

  • Three-way Nationals race looms

    Three-way Nationals race looms

    A THREE-way contest is set to decide the next Nationals candidate for one of northern Victoria’s safest seats, with party members to choose a successor to retiring heavyweight Peter Walsh…

  • Walk in the park for Parkinson’s

    Walk in the park for Parkinson’s

    A REGIONAL Parkinson’s walk is set to bring communities together this weekend, with organisers urging locals to step out, connect and support those living with the condition. Swan Hill Parkinson’s…