Home » Letters to the Editor » Spurious claims on shooting

Spurious claims on shooting

THE chief executive of Field & Game Australia waxes lyrical about Australia’s “deep-seated hunting tradition” (Anger over go-ahead, Gannawarra Times, February 20).

He overlooks the deep-seated community rejection of duck shooting that led to a ban across two-thirds of our continent (NSW, Queensland and WA).

Professor Kingsford (UNSW) has surveyed waterbirds over four decades, revealing long-term decline of most hunted species. That’s awkward for shooters, so they snipe at his work.

In 2021, Kingsford finally refuted those criticisms, but the Andrews government had already promised millions of our taxes for new surveys and computer models. This is the “scientifically driven season-setting process” touted by FGA.

Last year, the Game Management Authority aimed for a reduced harvest because duck populations had not recovered despite rains. The computer model came up with a lower bag limit and the Minister even shortened GMA’s recommended season. The result? The harvest was bang-on the long-term average – no reduction at all.

Few would believe FGA’s spurious claim that “scientific research” shows the recreational shooting of Australian native ducks and quail has a “positive impact on habitat conservation and wildlife management”.

Finally, it’s a bit rich for FGA to label its opponents a “minority”. Only two in a thousand Victorians shoot ducks. And a 2019 government report disclosed that most game hunters don’t belong to any hunting club at all.

Em Wilkinson

Wattle Park, Victoria

Digital Editions


More News

  • Heart of songwriting remains unchanged

    Heart of songwriting remains unchanged

    AUSTRALIAN country music star Sara Storer has spent decades turning everyday bush moments into songs. The stories, she says, are everywhere. You just have to recognise the ones worth telling.…

  • Child protection bills pass Parliament

    Child protection bills pass Parliament

    TWO landmark child protection bills passed the Victorian Parliament last week, introducing changes aimed at giving families more time to reunite and creating a new whole-of-government responsibility for children in…

  • Hotel future unclear

    Hotel future unclear

    THE Gannawarra Shire Council has provided an update on the Cohuna Hotel following claims made by its owner in separate court proceedings that the property had been issued with an…

  • Food price warning over fuel fears

    Food price warning over fuel fears

    AUSTRALIANS are being warned every corner of the economy will be affected by soaring fuel prices as a result of the war in Iran. But consumers are being urged to…

  • Time to rediscover Kirra

    Time to rediscover Kirra

    There’s something about Kirra, from the pristine open beach to the laidback community vibe to the latest restaurant openings – it’s a popular seaside destination. Back in the day Kirra…

  • Just a question of price

    Just a question of price

    After a string of hybrid and fully-electric vehicles, including a full-blown electric ute, it was kind of refreshing to get behind the wheel of a no-frills turbo-diesel 4×4 ute like…

  • Farmers short on fuel

    Farmers short on fuel

    MEMBER for Mallee Anne Webster says Mallee farmers have warned the Middle East conflict is depriving them of the fuel needed to feed and clothe the nation. Dr Webster said…

  • New funds for local clubs

    New funds for local clubs

    TWENTY-three sporting clubs in the upper house Victorian electoral district will share in $200,000 in the latest round of grants to support community participation. The move comes via the Sporting…

  • Police search for missing males

    Police search for missing males

    POLICE are appealing for public assistance in locating two missing males. Fourteen-year-old Byron was last seen in Swan Hill on 24 February. He is known to frequent the Mildura, Bendigo,…

  • Nominate a natural hero

    Nominate a natural hero

    THE 2026 Victorian and New South Wales Landcare Awards have officially opened for nominations. The biennial state programs recognise individuals, groups, and organisations involved in landcare who are making outstanding…